Top 10 Best fireplace grates in 2025

Introduction

Looking for a reliable fireplace grates in 2025? You’re not alone. With so many models available today, it’s easy to get lost—especially when descriptions are vague or customer reviews are all over the place. That’s why we decided to sort things out. Not by claiming to know everything, but by analyzing what sells well, what real users say, and what’s worth your attention both on paper and in practice. Our goal isn’t to drown you in technical details, but to guide you toward the best possible choices—without wasting hours comparing on your own. In short, a practical and hopefully useful guide.

See the full ranking

Our Top 3

N° 1
Your Diy Shop Victorian Black Cast Iron Fire Screen for 16" Open Fireplace
  • Timeless Design: Evokes the charm of Victorian era with its elegant style
  • Durable Construction: Crafted from heavy-duty cast iron for longevity
  • Perfect Fit: Designed to fit 16-inch open fireplaces
  • Easy to Clean: Blackened finish resists soot and is simple to maintain
  • Safety First: Protects from sparks and rolling logs with its sturdy design
PromoN° 2
Inglenook 16" Fire Grate Cast Iron Stool Coal Log Fireplace Black Front Open Basket
  • Fire Grate for a 16" fireplace (measures approx 15'' wide)
  • Cast iron fire grate is an essential addition to your fireplace
  • The curved design at the front ensures that no fuel will spill forwards
  • Eco friendly
  • Width: 38cm Depth: 28cm Height: 12cm
PromoN° 3
Stax Hearth & Home Cast Iron Fire Grate for 16 Inch Opening Heavy Duty Fire Log Coal Fireplace Rack, Black
  • Hearth & Home cast iron fire grate 16 inch.
  • This traditional style fireplace grate with 4 legs is made from a heavy cast iron construction (3.5kg) making the grate extremely robust and durable for all your needs.
  • Its curved design provides extra capacity which allows you to hold plenty of coals or logs on your open fire, perfect for stocking up and keeping warm.
  • The 4 sturdy legs also allows room beneath for use of an ashpan, ensuring that your fireplace is kept tidy and allows easy removal of ash when not in use.
  • The grate measures an overall size of L 35cm x D 26cm x H 10cm making it suitable for use with a 16-inch opening. Finished in a modern plain black colour, the grate makes a perfect addition to any fireplace, modern or traditional.

How to choose a good fireplace grates?

On the surface, choosing a fireplace grates seems simple. But once you dig in, it gets more complicated. Between technical differences, unfamiliar brands, and unclear features, it’s better to ask the right questions:

  • Usage: Will you use it daily or only occasionally? That heavily influences the right model.
  • Budget: No need to go for the most expensive one right away. What matters is the value for money.
  • Key factors:
    • Durability, build quality, lifespan
    • Truly useful features (not just marketing buzz)
    • User reviews, especially after weeks or months
    • Availability of customer service in case of issues

We’ve cross-checked multiple sources: Amazon data, detailed reviews, search trends… and a bit of intuition too—because numbers don’t tell the whole story. This mix allows us to build our ranking, which we update regularly. The goal isn’t to just list names but to guide you toward what truly works.

Our Top 10 Best fireplace grates

N° 1
Your Diy Shop Victorian Black Cast Iron Fire Screen for 16" Open Fireplace
  • Timeless Design: Evokes the charm of Victorian era with its elegant style
  • Durable Construction: Crafted from heavy-duty cast iron for longevity
  • Perfect Fit: Designed to fit 16-inch open fireplaces
  • Easy to Clean: Blackened finish resists soot and is simple to maintain
  • Safety First: Protects from sparks and rolling logs with its sturdy design
PromoN° 2
Inglenook 16" Fire Grate Cast Iron Stool Coal Log Fireplace Black Front Open Basket
  • Fire Grate for a 16" fireplace (measures approx 15'' wide)
  • Cast iron fire grate is an essential addition to your fireplace
  • The curved design at the front ensures that no fuel will spill forwards
  • Eco friendly
  • Width: 38cm Depth: 28cm Height: 12cm
PromoN° 3
Stax Hearth & Home Cast Iron Fire Grate for 16 Inch Opening Heavy Duty Fire Log Coal Fireplace Rack, Black
  • Hearth & Home cast iron fire grate 16 inch.
  • This traditional style fireplace grate with 4 legs is made from a heavy cast iron construction (3.5kg) making the grate extremely robust and durable for all your needs.
  • Its curved design provides extra capacity which allows you to hold plenty of coals or logs on your open fire, perfect for stocking up and keeping warm.
  • The 4 sturdy legs also allows room beneath for use of an ashpan, ensuring that your fireplace is kept tidy and allows easy removal of ash when not in use.
  • The grate measures an overall size of L 35cm x D 26cm x H 10cm making it suitable for use with a 16-inch opening. Finished in a modern plain black colour, the grate makes a perfect addition to any fireplace, modern or traditional.
N° 4
Inglenook 4.86kg 16inch Heavy Duty Cast Iron Fireside Log Coal Fire Grate, Black
  • Traditional 4 leg fire grate, Designed to fit a 16 inch grate
  • Please note the grate might be smaller than the fireplace size, this is so you can add logs, fuel, bricks and cement.
  • Iron Fireside Log GrateThis fire grate is constructed from quality cast iron and is an essential component for every open fire, with four sturdy legs,
  • This reliable and robust fire grate has a scooped design to contain your solid fuel. Furthermore this fire grate is durable and strong, offering you great value for money
N° 5
Fire Vida Laxton Solid Fuel Fireplace Grate Set – Cast Iron Fire Grate with Ash Pan & Fire Front – Black & Chrome Open Fire Accessories – Ideal for Fireplaces, Coal Fires & Log Burners
  • Complete Open Fire Set – Includes solid fuel fire grate, ash pan, and chrome-detailed fire front; ideal for open fireplaces, log burners, and coal fires.
  • Durable Cast Iron Construction – Built to withstand high temperatures; a heavy-duty fire grate set that provides strength, longevity, and performance.
  • Efficient Combustion Design – The open design of the coal grate promotes airflow for a hotter, more consistent burn and improved fuel efficiency.
  • Easy to Clean Ashpan – The removable ash pan catches debris and ashes for quick, mess-free fireplace maintenance.
  • Safe & Stylish Fire Front – Chrome-accented fire front adds a layer of protection while enhancing the look of your fire basket setup.
N° 6
Vintage Decor® WW Victorian Premium Grade Cast Iron Fire Grate with Removable Coal Saver Guard Heavy Duty 5kg > 16 Inch Fireplace opening 4 Legs Matt Black Heat Resistant Finish Ready to use Open Fire
  • PREMIUM GRADE 5KG: Made from premium cast iron ore which gives its density and weight of 5kg whereas others are much lighter ie. 3kg this results in the grate cracking splitting because of impure cast iron ie. recycled metals and thinner gauge. Will not be disappointed with this grate made to a high standard. DIMENSIONS: Grate Widest point 38.5cm ,Deepest 23cm, Shortest edge is 9cm Side 19cm Legs 8cm high Guard 9cm high FIREPLACE OPENING SIZE: Suitable for fireplace opening size of 16 Inch
  • HEAT RESISTANT PAINT FINISH: Ready to use finished in a quality matt black heat resistant finish up to 600 degrees C, most other grates are unfinished and require painting to cover the filing marks from the foundry READY: ready to use straight away out of the box This fire grate is constructed from quality cast iron and is an essential component for every open fire. With four sturdy legs, this reliable and robust fire grate has a angled design to contain your solid fuel..
  • TIP:To get the best results from your grate the hot coals should be regularly "riddled" with a poker. This helps ash to fall through the grate into the ash collecting tray, allowing air to flow in. The increased airflow feeds the flames and also prevents a build-up of excessive heat which would damage the ironwork. Distinctive product with a modern design, the cast iron fire grate
  • 4 LEGS: good stability & tapered square finish using a smaller footprint and symmetrical to the angles of the grate aesthetically pleasing suitable for burning solid fuels such as coals & logs| Eco friendly Nostalgia Retro look essential addition to your fireplace With four sturdy legs allowing it to stand freely in the fireplace opening and to allow room for an ash pan, this reliable & robust fire grate has a coal guard to contain your solid fuel such as coals, wood log, very durable & strong,
  • AMBIANCE: Bring a Cosy Atmosphere Have you ever heard anyone say there’s nothing quite like the gentle hum of an electric fire or the silent flickers of gas? No, that’s because no one ever does. It may be strictly from an aesthetically pleasing point of view, but curling up on the sofa, the flames crackling and spitting in the fireplace, creates a much stronger ambiance. benefit of a fireplace is that it acts as a focal point for family and friends to gather around to share drinks
N° 7
LESS THAN HALF PRICE - REDUCED TO CLEAR - Inglenook Open Fire Grate Log Coal Wood Basket Holder Black Heavy Duty Cast Iron
  • Heavy duty cast iron grate
  • Suitable for wood or coal fires
  • WIDTH:39CM DEPTH 26CM HEIGHT FROM FLOOR :20CM
  • Air holes to help fire breathe
  • Brand new, in stock, fast despatch
N° 8
Castle Heavy Duty Grate Set - 16 Inch Fire Front Fret Matt Black
  • Designed to enhance your fireplace experience, this traditional-style fireplace set includes a cast iron grate, cast iron castle fire front fret and matching ashpan
  • The curved design of the grate provides extra capacity which allows you to hold plenty of coals or logs on your open fire, perfect for stocking up and keeping warm and toasty. The 16-inch fire fret is designed to be placed in front of an open fire and works perfectly when paired with the matching ash pan.
  • The grate measures 37.5cm in width at the front, and width at the Back: 26cm, 28cm front to back and stands 11cm high at the front there is 7cm clearance space under the grate to allow for the ash pan making it suitable for use with a 16-inch opening. Finished in a modern plain black colour, the grate makes a perfect addition to any fireplace, modern or traditional.
  • The fire front measures 20cm (h) x 39cm (W) with a depth of 8.5cm The fret is designed to sit in front of a 16-inch fire grate and 16-inch ashpan. Typically placed in front of the fire opening, covering the fireplace grate and ash pan.
  • Designed to combine both functionality and style, this set is a popular choice for those who want to add a touch of elegance to their traditional fireplace.
N° 9
Inglenook 14" Fire Grate
  • Fire Grate for the 14 " fireplace
  • Longest side is 33 cm
  • Shortest side width is 22 cm
  • Height is 12 cm of the longest side

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the best fireplace grates?
It depends on your needs, but the top 3 products are generally the most balanced options.

How do I maintain it properly?
It varies by model. The best approach is to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations (yes, reading the manual is worth it).

Where to buy it with confidence?
Amazon remains a solid choice: wide selection, easy returns, and tons of user reviews—hard to beat.

Do I need a big-name brand?
Not necessarily. Lesser-known brands can be surprisingly good, with well-designed products that rival top names—at a lower cost. Don’t overlook them just because the name is unfamiliar.

What are the most common pitfalls?
A super low price might be tempting but could signal major compromises (build quality, reliability, nonexistent support…). Also beware of product pages with no reviews or vague comments. Spend a few minutes reading real feedback—this is often where the most valuable info is.

How is our ranking built?

We don’t claim to have a magic formula. In reality, it’s a blend of data—ratings, sales volume, review frequency—and observation. We watch for recurring themes in reviews, compare search trends, and yes, sometimes rely on our gut feeling. A great product isn’t just numbers. Our ranking aims to balance all of that: data, common sense, and a lot of time spent checking.

We analyze scores, sales frequency, genuine reviews (not just stars), and current search trends. Each model is rated using a consistent set of criteria. While it’s not perfect, it helps us stay fair and consistent. And we update our lists often, because products evolve—and so do we.

Why trust Topelio?

Topelio is an independent website—we don’t sell these products and we’re not tied to any brand. What drives us is clarity and usefulness. We aim to produce practical, readable, honest content. Our rankings are based on public data, complemented by our own experience. No shady partnerships or biased recommendations—just a genuine effort to save you time, and maybe money too.

See all fireplace grates on Amazon

Conclusion

Thanks for taking the time to read this guide. Choosing a fireplace grates might seem trivial, but it’s often more complicated than expected. Too many options, unclear product pages, and marketing promises that don’t help… That’s why we aimed to create a simple but solid comparison. With practical info, useful tips, and most importantly—a ranking based on reality. Take time to compare, read more reviews if needed, and choose based on your own priorities. What works for someone else might not be ideal for you. If this guide helped you, feel free to explore our other articles. We always try to add real value—without wasting your time. See you soon on Topelio.

Leave a comment